Badger Vaccination: A Vacation from Culling

Badger - Credit Mark Davison

Bovine tuberculosis is the one of the most serious diseases currently threatening the UK farming industry [1]. The incidence of the disease has generally increased since the 1980s throughout England and Wales, with Scotland being TB-free since 2009 (bar isolated cases from imported cattle) [2]. The UK now has some of the highest rates of bovine TB in Europe [3]. Like tuberculosis in humans, bovine TB primarily affects the lungs and airways [4], but it can also cause a loss of appetite resulting in severe weight loss, fever, swollen lymph nodes in the neck and udder infections [5]. It can takes months or even years for an infected animal to die and the disease can be spread to others before any symptoms begin to appear in the infected individual [6]. As bovine TB is a zoonotic disease it can also be passed on to humans, although this risk is very low due to the pasteurisation of dairy products (which removes the disease), extensive meat inspection and farms being restricted where an infected animal causes a “herd breakdown” [7].

In just one year (2010 to 2011), nearly 25,000 cattle had to be slaughtered as a result of restrictions put in place to try and control the disease [8]. As well as the suffering and subsequent loss of life for the animals and the economic loss to the farmer, it has been estimated that in the past ten years attempts to control bovine TB have resulted in a £500 million cost to taxpayers in England alone [9].

Badgers, an iconic animal of British wildlife, have been identified as “wildlife reservoirs”, carrying and transmitting the disease to cattle without suffering from any symptoms themselves [10]. This has resulted in England and Ireland allowing the culling (or killing) of badgers to try and prevent disease transmission to cattle, despite badgers only being responsible for roughly 6% of herd infections [11].

Badgers are killed either by controlled shooting — carried out by so-called trained cull marksmen — or by being trapped in a cage and then shot at close range [12]. Currently there are 32 badger cull areas in England, including Dorset, Cornwall, Devon, Gloucestershire, Herefordshire, Cheshire, Somerset, Wiltshire, Cumbria and Staffordshire [13].

Because of the nature of the disease, a targeted amount of badgers need to be culled to see a significant reduction: approximately 70% of the badger population in a 60 square mile radius. If this target is not achieved bovine TB in cattle may increase due to greater movement of badgers once culling has begun, also known as the perturbation effect [14]. The higher density of badgers in Britain has resulted in both increased and decreased rates of bovine TB in cattle [15].

Leading vets and animal welfare experts have criticised the government for falsely claiming that culling has effectively reduced bovine TB rates in Gloucestershire and Somerset, the original badger pilot cull areas.  The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), has focused solely on how many new cases of bovine TB have occurred within a herd. Experts state that Defra ought to be focusing on the percentage of herds in culling zones that already have the disease. In fact, rather than helping to decrease rates of bovine TB , the killing of over 1,700 badgers each in both Gloucestershire and Somerset has had no effect in controlling the disease [16].

Along with concerns about how effective culling is as a means of curbing the spread of bovine TB, there is the issue of to what extent individual badgers suffer in the process. An independent scientific assessment of the 2013 pilot badger culls found that 18% of badgers culled took longer than five minutes to die, failing to fulfil the requirement of a “humane” death [17].

Research has also proven that bovine TB is not transmitted from badgers to cattle through direct contact. Professor Rosie Woodroffe led a field study in 2016 to see exactly how the disease is transmitted between the two species, focusing exclusively on Cornish farms [18]. With very little physical interaction occurring (understandably badgers preferred to keep their distance from herds of cattle), it was assumed instead that both badger to cattle and cattle to cattle transmission happens through the environment [19]. This means that even if bovine TB is detected in a herd or individual, isolation does not necessarily eradicate the disease completely. There are also concerns that the standardised test used for detecting the disease misses some infected individuals, meaning that cattle moved around the country may then go on to infect other herds [20].

Having recently moved back to Derbyshire where I grew up, I was happy to discover that the Derbyshire Wildlife Trust (DWT) has been instrumental in preventing culling, implementing a badger vaccination scheme instead. Not only has the vaccination proved to be significantly cheaper than culling (around 20 times less expensive, even with the DWT having to source their own vaccine from Canada) it has also gained support from numerous other organisations such as the National Farmers Union, illustrating a significant shift in attitude and support for this alternate method of control for bovine TB [21]. The DWT badger vaccination programme is now the largest and most effective scheme in the country [22]. Read more about what they are doing here.

BCG (or Bacillus Calmette-Guerin) is a strain of bovine TB used as a vaccine for humans, previously thought only to limit the extent of the disease rather than as a preventative measure [23]. However more recent studies in humans, possums, ferrets, wild boar, mice, guinea pigs and cattle show that this may no longer be the case [24]. The vaccine was licensed for use in badgers in 2010 [25]. BCG can be administered to badgers orally or through an intramuscular injection.

Unfortunately, most methods of vaccination involve trapping which may itself be a welfare concern if the animal becomes injured or stressed. Trapping may also result in an uneven distribution of vaccinated badgers within a population as some individual animals may be “trap-shy” and will therefore never receive the vaccine. An alternative is oral baits, which can be used in free roaming badgers which removes the necessary confinement, but then makes it difficult to control how much vaccine has been administered to which badgers [26].

BCG vaccination for badgers has so far proved successful. The social structures within communal setts make an ideal focal point for administering the vaccine [27]. A short captive study carried out by Carter et al found vaccination to be beneficial both in directly reducing the levels of TB in individuals and indirectly reducing the risk of unvaccinated cubs contracting TB, most likely through herd immunity [28].

Although it is undeniable that badger vaccination cannot and will not be the sole solution to bovine TB, it can significantly contribute to the multi-factorial approach that the government ought to adopt if they truly wish to wipe out this disease [29]. It is clear that cattle ought also be vaccinated, that there should be stricter movement controls to prevent the disease spreading through transportation, better bio-security on farms to remove the disease from the environment, and an improved test that is more accurate in detecting the disease [30].

As Woodroffe warns, “the benefits of badger culling accrue really slowly but the harmful effects (such as spreading TB more widely) happen really fast.” [31] It would make more sense to take the substantial money and resources used by the government for badger culling and invest in better bio-security for farmers if they hope to completely eliminate the disease [32]. Bovine TB is a horrific disease for which cattle suffer greatly, but to me it would appear badgers have little to do with it. Vaccinating badgers would be more beneficial in reducing the “wildlife reservoir” of bovine TB, as well as being cheaper, safer and more humane than culling. We can instead protect this important species that is symbolic of British wildlife.


References

Journal Articles

Carter, Chambers, Rushton, Shirley, Schuchert, Pietravalle, Murray, Rogers, Gettingby, Smith, Delahay, Hewinson and McDonald, ‘BCG Vaccination Reduces Risk of Tuberculosis Infection in Vaccinated Badgers and Unvaccinated Badger Cubs’, PLoS ONE (2012) 7(12)   — [1] [8] [15] [28]

Chambers, Rogers, Delahay, Lesellier, Ashford, Dalley, Gowtage, Dave,  Palmer, Brewer, Crawshaw, Clifton-Hadley, Carter, Cheeseman, Hanks, Murray, Palphramand, Pietravalle, Smith, Tomlinson, Walker, Wilson, Corner, Rushton, Shirley, Gettinby, McDonald and Hewinson, ‘Bacillus Calmette-Guerin vaccination reduces the severity and progression of tuberculosis in badgers’, Proceedings of the Royal Society B (2010) 278, 1913–1920 –– [23] [24] 

Chambers, Carter, Wilson, Jones, Brown, Hewinson and Vordermeir, ‘Vaccination against tuberculosis in badgers and cattle: an overview of the challenges, developments and current research priorities in Great Britain’ Veterinary Record (2014) 175, 90-96 — [1] [2] [9] [10] [11] [29]

Corner, Costello, O’Meara, Lesellier, Aldwell, Signh, Hewinsone, Chambers and Gormley, ‘Oral vaccination of badgers (Meles meles) with BCG and protective immunity against endobronchial challenge with Mycobacterium bovis’, Vaccine (2010) 28, 6265-6272 — [24]

Delahay, Wilson, Smith and Cheeseman, ‘Vaccinating badgers (Meles meles) against Mycobacterium bovis: the ecological considerations’, The Veterinary Journal (2003) 166, 43-51 — [27]

Maye, Enticott, lbery, Fisher and Kirwan, ‘Assessing Farmer Confidence in Badger Vaccination: Some Findings from a Survey of Cattle Farmers in England’, Journal of Rural and Community Development (2013) 8(3), 49-64 — [25]

Robinson, Corner, Courcier, McNair, Artois, Menzies and Abernethy, ‘BCG vaccination against tuberculosis in European badgers (Meles meles): A review’, Comparative Immunology, Microbiology and Infectious Diseases (2012) 35, 277-287 — [3] [26]

Wilkinson, Smith, Delahay and Cheeseman, ‘A model of bovine tuberculosis in the badger Meles meles: an evaluation of different vaccination strategies’, Journal of Applied Ecology (2004) 41, 492-501 — [7]

News Articles

Damian Carrington, ‘Bovine TB not passed on through direct contact with badgers, research shows’, The Guardian 5 August 2016, accessed 15 November 2018 — [11] [18] [19] [31] [32]

Damian Carrington, ‘Farming industry to blame for TB crisis, not just badgers – report’, The Guardian, 13 November 2018, accessed 15 November 2018 — [20]

Jamie Doward, ‘Minister’s claim that badger cull cuts cattle TB is attacked by experts’, The Guardian, 21 October 2018, accessed 15 November 2018 — [16]

Jamie Dorward, ‘Secret filming reveals hidden cruelty of licensed badger culls’, The Guardian, 30 September 2018, accessed 15 November 2018 — [13] [17]

Pallab Gosh, ‘Has Defra shown that badger culling stems cattle TB?’, BBC Science and Environment, 28 August 2015, accessed 15 November 2018 — [14]

Pallab Gosh, ‘Badger culls were ineffective and failed humaneness test’, BBC Science and Environment, 28 February 2014, accessed 15 November 2018 — [17]

Websites

Defra, ‘Bovine TB: how to spot and report the disease’, 26 August 2014, accessed 13 November 2018 — [5] [7]

Defra, ‘Setting the minimum and maximum numbers in badger cull areas in 2018: Advice to Natural England’, 13 September 2018, accessed 15 November 2018 — [13]

Derbyshire Wildlife Trust, ‘Badger vaccination’, accessed 15 November 2018 — [13] [21] [30]

Derbyshire Wildlife Trust, ‘100th Badger Vaccinated’, accessed 15 November 2018 — [14] [21]

Derbyshire Wildlife Trust, ‘200th Badger Vaccinated’, accessed 15 November 2018 — [22]

Humane Society International, ‘Facts About England’s Badger Cull’, accessed 15 November 2018 — [12]

NHS, ‘Is eating meat infected with bovine TB harmful?’, 1 July 2013, accessed 13 November 2018 — [4] [7]

World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE), ‘Bovine Tuberculosis’ General Disease Information Sheet, accessed 15 November 2018 — [6]

 

REVIEW: ‘Carnage’

Veganism is a tricky subject. Although it is rapidly growing as a movement, with the Vegan Society reporting in 2016 that half a million of people in the UK are now leading a vegan lifestyle, it still remains a minority in a society of carnivores. I’m sure that everyone knows or has encountered at least one self-righteous, or what I like to call ‘crusading’, vegan. A vegan who believes that their moral high ground gives them the authority to alienate those not following the same lifestyle. Despite this stereotype representing a small cross-section of a relatively small community, it has nonetheless stigmatised the vegan movement to the point that the wider public can dismiss every single vegan as some kind of extremist elitist.

This is what makes the mockumentary ‘Carnage: Swallowing the Past’ so clever. Not only was it created by one of my favourite comedians Simon Amstell, (of ‘Popworld’, ‘Never Mind the Buzzcocks’ and ‘Grandma’s House’) with the music by Jeremy Warmsley (aka Mr Summer Camp, another personal favourite) it also manages to put forward the main arguments for veganism in a hilarious, concise and positive manner. It also, between the gags, brings up many of the key discussion points in animal welfare and veganism today.

‘‘Carnage’ is framed as a documentary made in the year 2067, a time where Britain has become an all-vegan society and where discussion of the country’s past of eating animal products is the ultimate taboo. Actors portray the younger generations that have grown up knowing nothing but a vegan way of life, perplexed by their elders who used to eat meat and drink the milk of ‘little babies’. The film aims to address the taboo by detailing the history of veganism, intensive farming and meat eating in British society, from 1944 through to “present” day. It does this through the use of  both archival and staged footage of TV clips, news reports and interviews with fictional activists, chefs and other important figures who played a part in veganism becoming the norm.

Amstell’s narration by comparing the farming of animals to the slave trade. He is not the first person to make this comparison. Animals have been likened to previously marginalised groups within society, because they are discriminated against on the basis of their species, rather than race, nationality or sexuality. It has been predicted that animals will be the next group to be relieved from persecution.

The hypocrisy of our current treatment of animals is also highlighted, with reference to the incident involving David Cameron and the head of a pig. If we are outraged by this sort of behaviour towards pigs, how do we justify killing and eating them?

Within society, trying to decide whether murder or rape is the worse crime is something that is not discussed. And it needn’t be. As humans, we see murder and rape as the most immoral acts that can be committed against one another. And yet, we casually commit both crimes, with animals as the victims, every day. Cannibalism between humans can only be justified as an act of last resort, for the purposes of survival, by those stranded and with little other choice. Rape and other sexual offences, meanwhile, occur in the absence of consent. Often, the targets of these offences are unable to consent, either through lack of communication or understanding, like children, the disabled, and animals. Amstell’s unapologetic use of the word ‘rape’ in reference to animals reflects this point of view, particularly talking about cows who are artificially inseminated in order to produce more milk for the dairy industry.

Bringing up all of these points throughout an otherwise comedic film supports Amstell’s overarching argument that the entire societal structure of Britain must be challenged in order to achieve the all-vegan future depicted in ‘Carnage’ (which is presumably Amstell’s desired future, what with him being a vegan himself).

Human beings do not need to eat animals. We have gone before without eating animal products, as Amstell recalls the rationing of animal products in the Second World War, leading to the ‘Dig for Victory’ campaign and encouragement for self sufficiency. It also not necessary for our diets, nor as a means to survival. Rather, we eat animals simply because we can. Our consumerist, capitalist culture has led to animals being commodified, an entire food industry based around the enslavement, rape and murder of living beings.

Ultimately, ‘Carnage’ offers three reasons why we should no longer eat animals: for the sake of the animals themselves, to help reduce the effects of climate change on the environment, and for the purposes of human health. Eating meat from animals pumped full of antibiotics and steroids leads to stronger diseases that could be passed on to humans through consumption (also known as zoonotic diseases.) It is particularly useful to recognise arguments for animal protection that do not rely on animals being saved for the sake of themselves, but instead show the negative impacts that their current treatment has on our society, such as human health. These arguments will help to further practical changes to implement in order to improve protection for animals.

For a documentary to be effective, I believe it needs to have two successful components. An interesting subject, and an effective presentation of said subject. The use of ‘anti-farm propaganda’ does crop up occasionally in ‘Carnage’, but it is by no means the focus. Rather than simply relying on shock value to convince people to give up animal products, Amstell instead addresses the actual issues. His brand of humour also makes it an easier watch, from the fictional musical within the film featuring the line, ‘What kind of animal rapes for milk?’, to the suggestion that Ronald McDonald’s hair is red because he swims in the blood of animals killed for their products.

Ronald McDonald Identity Crisis

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free